Man at ticket machine

Picture copyright
Getty Photographs

Rail ticket machines trigger a lot confusion that one-fifth of passengers who use them purchase the incorrect ticket, in response to the rail regulator.

Whereas 7% of individuals underpay and might be fined, 13% are paying an excessive amount of.

The Workplace of Rail and Street (ORR) needs practice firms to refund passengers who by accident purchase tickets which can be too costly for his or her journey.

Prepare operators stated that merchandising machines had been designed for easy ticket necessities.

They are saying plans to simplify fares will assist them to offer clearer data on ticket machines.

The ORR employed mystery shoppers to purchase rail tickets from machines.

  • Practically two-thirds (65%) couldn’t see any data on the machines about the kind of tickets which might or couldn’t be purchased
  • Greater than half (57%) stated the machines didn’t clarify the instances when peak and off-peak tickets had been legitimate
  • And almost one-third (32%) stated there was no data on the machines about ticket restrictions

“Regardless of funding in new know-how and the removing of jargon from ticket machines, our new analysis reveals passengers could also be paying extra for his or her journey than crucial,” stated John Larkinson, ORR director of railway markets and economics.

“We’re calling on practice firms to decide to refund anybody who finds that they may have purchased a less expensive ticket for a similar journey,” he added.

Rail operators C2C and Scotrail have already got a value assure in place for when passengers overpay.


Earlier this month, the Rail Supply Group (RDG), which represents practice operators, introduced a trial scheme to simplify fares.

It stated the 16 million fares on supply had been “baffling” for passengers.

As a part of the trial, which begins in Could, ticket machines on stations may even be up to date, to verify they present the most cost effective fares obtainable.

“To shortly profit passengers, the Rail Supply Group should set out what enhancements to ticket machines might be made within the brief time period,” stated Mr Larkinson.

Paul Plummer, chief govt of the RDG, instructed the BBC that operators had been conscious that there was an issue with machines, and that they’d formulated a 10-point plan to enhance them.

But he identified the machines had been designed as “queue-busters” for passengers with comparatively easy necessities, however “expectations [of passengers] had developed”.

He stated that the system of fares was far too sophisticated.

The RDG additionally added: “Complicated, decades-old authorities rail fare laws make it tougher for practice firms to supply the suitable, easy choices on ticket machines.

“Simplifying the quantity and kinds of fares within the system will let practice firms present clients with clear data and assist them to make higher knowledgeable selections,” they added.

Why are UK rail fares so sophisticated?

by Ben Morris, enterprise reporter

Within the British Rail period, rail fares had been a comparatively easy affair, with ticket costs labored out on a cost-per mile foundation.

However within the 1990s, in an effort to make the community extra environment friendly, the operation of rail companies was handed to non-public practice working firms (Tocs).

The Tocs got some freedom to set ticket costs, with superior ticket bookings notably essential to them, because it helps them to maintain their trains full.

To guard passengers, different fares had been regulated, together with season tickets and off-peak fares.

The result’s a patchwork of fares, that turns into much more sophisticated when a passenger needs to cross a number of practice areas.

Savvy travellers have been profiting from this by splitting their journey into a number of tickets, moderately than one through-ticket.